The Best Innerspring Mattress Reviews

Innerspring MattressInnerspring mattresses are direct competitors to memory foam or visco-elastic foam mattresses. They utilize a core of springs or coils to provide support. There are different types of coil systems and each of them has their pros and cons. The 4 most common coil systems are Bonnell, Continuous, Offset and Pocketed coils. Some manufacturers also design their own coil system and usually, it is based on one of the 4 above, with some improvements.

Coil count and coil gauge are also important factors that determine the price and quality of an innerspring mattress. Coil count is the number of coils and coil gauge is the thickness of the wire used. A high coil count and thick coil gauge equals good support, durability and quality.

The comfort layer or the top layer of an innerspring mattress is usually made up of different types of materials. It can have a comfort layer of memory foam, latex or various foams and most of the time, a euro top or a pillow top. Some manufacturers, though, use additional set of coils in their comfort layer. This is a coil on coil system and it is only found in high-end mattresses.

Pros

  • Budget and mid-range innerspring mattresses are widely available online and at retail stores.
  • This type of mattress offers all kinds of firmness and comfort levels that can satisfy anyone’s budget.
  • Budget and mid-range innerspring mattresses are relatively cheaper than their memory foam or latex counterparts.
  • Innerspring mattresses tend to sleep cooler because of the airflow between the springs.
  • Great for couples that are sexually active due to the springiness/bounciness.

Cons

  • A low quality innerspring mattress can develop sagging and squeaking noise very fast.
  • Durability and longevity is also a problem with low quality models.
  • Availability of higher quality/high end innerspring mattresses online is low.

Best Innerspring Mattresses – Luxury and Mid Range

These are the innerspring mattresses that we highly recommend for regular use. These are made with high quality materials and will surely last a long time. These are also from well established and highly reputable brands. Specs and prices are for the queen size.

Click on the image to view the product page
MattressPrice RangeCoil SystemComfort LayerRating
Saatva 14.5" Luxury Firm Mattress
saatva luxury firm mattress
$$$$Coil-on-Coil 416 Hourglass Shaped + 884 Individually Wrapped CoilsMemory foam layer + Euro Pillow Top4.9/5
Aviya Mattress
$$$$800 Individually Wrapped Coils3 layers of high density foam4.8/5
Crave Mattress
$$$$Individually Wrapped Coils1.5" Egg crate 3 zone latex foam,
1.5" Memory foam
4.7/5
Classic Brands Mercer 12"
Classic Brands Mercer
$$768 Individually Wrapped CoilsGel memory foam + layers of comfort foam4.3/5
Ultimate Dreams 12" Pocketed Coils Pillow Top
Ultimate Dreams Pocketed Coil
$$$750 Pocketed Coils
Pillow Top with soft foams4.3/5

Saatva Luxury Firm Mattress – Best Overall Innerspring Mattress

saatva luxury firm mattressThe Saatva Luxury Firm Mattress is the best innerspring mattress that we recommend overall because the mattress is constructed with superior support and comfort in mind by using a coil-on-coil design. What we also like is its affordability despite the high end construction of the mattress. The queen sized Saatva mattress is priced at $999 and this is a rare thing because mattresses with a coil-on-coil design are usually priced at over $2000. The mattress is very affordable because Saatva is an online brand and they don’t have unnecessary expenses that they pass onto consumers.

The mattress is made in the USA, has a 15 year warranty and you can try it for 120 days before deciding if you want to keep it or return it.

  • Coil System: Coil on Coil: 416 Hourglass Shaped Coils + 884 Individually Wrapped Coils
  • Comfort Layer:  Lumbar support enhancement made of high quality memory foam, Euro Pillow Top
  • Fabric: Organic Cotton
  • Firmness:  Custom – Choose from Plush Soft, Luxury Firm or Firm
  • Thickness: 14.5″ or 11.5″
  • Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal-King
  • Product Page: Official Website

The Saatva mattress has a unique coil on coil design with 416 hourglass shaped coils 13 gauge and 884 individually wrapped coils 14.5 gauge to make for a total of 1300 coil count. The mattress has a steel edge support for better durability and wider sleep surface. There is also a lumbar support made from high quality memory foam to relieve tension on your lower back area – Certipur-US certified. The mattress is wrapped in organic cotton, one of the components in their green initiative. Read more.

Aviya Mattress

The Aviya Mattress is another very good mattress that we can highly recommend. The design of the mattress is very simple and it does the job very well in terms of giving you comfort and ample support. As for the firmness levels, you can choose from soft, luxury firm or firm. One of the areas that this mattress performs very well in is cooling. Since it only has standard foam in the comfort layer, rising temperature as you sleep will never be a problem.

The mattress comes with a 10 year warranty and a 100 night sleep trial. It is made in the USA and the queen sized model is priced at $ 899.

  • Support Layer: 800 Individually Wrapped Coils
  • Comfort Layer: 3 Layers of High Density Foams
  • Fabric: 1″ Quilted comfort foam
  • Firmness: Soft/Plush, Luxury Firm, Firm
  • Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal-King
  • Thickness: 13″
  • Product Page: Official Website

The Aviya mattress has 800 individually wrapped coils in the support layer and for the comfort layer, it uses 3 layers of high density foams. The foams used are CertiPUR certified. As for the edges, the mattress uses a 3″ encasing that spans the whole mattress for better edge support so you won’t roll off.

Crave Mattress

The Crave Mattress is a hybrid innerspring mattress that has latex and memory foam in the comfort layer. The combination of latex and memory foam works very well and it will be able to provide you with very good comfort. The mattress has a Plush feel so if you prefer a softer mattress, this is highly recommended. However, if you want a different feel, you should choose something else.

The mattress is made in the USA and it has a 10 year warranty. It is priced at $890 for the queen and you will be able to test the mattress for 100 nights before deciding if you want to keep it or return it.

  • Support Layer: Individually Wrapped Coils
  • Comfort Layer: 1.5″ Egg Crate 3 zone Latex foam, 1.5″ Memory Foam
  • Fabric: Poly Nylon Blend
  • Firmness: Plush
  • Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal-King
  • Thickness: 12″
  • Product Page: Official Website

The design of the Crave mattress features both memory foam and latex in the comfort layer and individually wrapped coils for support. The combination of latex and memory foam provides very good comfort without the “sinking” feeling that is prevalent in memory foam only mattresses. The latex layer is bouncier and more responsive so it’s easier to move.

Classic Brands Mercer 12″ Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid

Classic Brands MercerThe Classic Brands Mercer is a mid range mattress that is worth your money. It is a 12″ innerspring and gel memory foam hybrid. The comfort layer is not made up entirely of gel memory foam. It also includes layers of comfort foam. The foams used in the mattress are CertiPUR-US certified. It has a 10 year warranty.

  • Support Layer: 768 Individually Wrapped Coils
  • Comfort Layer: Layers of comfort foam + gel memory foam
  • Fabric: Stretch Knit Quilted Cover
  • Firmness: Medium Firm – Firm
  • Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal-King
  • Thickness: 12″
  • Product Page: Click Here

The comfort layer of the Classic Brands Mercer consists of several comfort foam and a layer of gel memory foam to enable a cooler sleeping experience. The mattress’ support layer consists of 768 individually wrapped coils and this means that the mattress has less bounce than innerspring mattresses that use other types of coils. However, this also means that it has better support, it minimizes motion transfer and it also allows the mattress to contour to your body more effectively. The foam used is Certipur-US certified so you can be sure of the quality of the foam and it is safe to sleep on. This is a very good mattress if you are looking to get a mid range innerspring mattress.

Dreamfoam Ultimate Dreams Pillow Top

Ultimate Dreams Pocketed CoilThe Ultimate Dreams Pillow Top is from DreamFoam Bedding, a family owned online brand that exclusively sells on Amazon. What we like most about the brand, aside from their quality mattresses, is that they offer direct factory pricing which means that consumers don’t have to pay extra. All their mattresses are made in the USA with strict emphasis on quality control. This is the best mid range innerspring mattress that we can recommend.

  • Support Layer: 750 Pocketed Coils
  • Comfort Layer: Pillow Top with soft foam
  • Fabric: Organic Cotton
  • Firmness: Soft – Medium Firm
  • Available Sizes: Twin, Full, Full XL, Queen, Short Queen, King, Cal-King
  • Thickness: 12″
  • Product Page: Click Here

The mattress  is 12″ thick and can be purchased with either a standard pillow top, a pillow top with latex or a pillow top with gel memory foam. The pillow top with latex includes 2 inches of 19ILD talalay latex and the pillow top with memory foam has 2 inches of gel memory foam. The support layer has 750 pocketed coils that can provide you with proper support while contouring to your body. Their foams are Certipur-US certified.


Best Budget Innerspring Mattresses

Budget innerspring mattresses are great for guest rooms or for temporary use. Of course, you can still use them as your everyday regular mattress but you shouldn’t expect too much of them. They are priced low because most of them only use regular polyurethane foam as the comfort layer, thus, sagging is a possibility. Some use specialty foams such as memory foam but that layer is usually pretty thin.

Click on the image to view the product page
MattressPrice RangeCoil SystemComfort LayerRating
Sleep Master 13" Deluxe Euro Box Top
Sleep Master 13-Inch Deluxe Euro Box Top
$$690 Pocketed Coils1.5" soft foam quilted,
3" soft foam and 1/2" high density foam

4.5/5
Signature Sleep Signature 13"
Signature Sleep Signature 13 Inch Mattress
$$744 Individually Wrapped CoilsPillow Top with Memory Foam,
3-zone foam layers
4.4/5
Night Therapy 13" Deluxe Euro Box Top
Night Therapy Deluxe
$$690 Pocketed Coils3" High density foam,
Quilted 2" euro top with 1.5" soft foam
4.4/5
Englander Finale 11"
Englander Finale
$$Individually Wrapped Coils
Plush top layer
Polyfoam
4.2/5

Sleep Master Ultima Deluxe Euro Box Top

Sleep Master 13-Inch Deluxe Euro Box TopThe Sleep Master 13″ Ultima Deluxe Euro Box Top Pocketed Spring Mattress is one of the best sellers in the innerspring mattress category on Amazon. This is a great value mattress that you can use as your regular mattress or for your guest room. Customers say that it is a medium firm – firm mattress so if you prefer a firmer mattress, this is a great choice.

  • Support Layer: 690 iCoils
  • Comfort Layer: 1.5″ soft foam quilted, 3″ soft foam and 1/2″ high density foam
  • Fabric: Quilted Jacquard Cover with Bamboo Rayon
  • Firmness: Medium firm – Firm
  • Available Sizes: Full, Queen, King
  • Thickness: 13″
  • Product Page: Click Here

The mattress is constructed with the iCoil system as the support base. The iCoil system is a variation of the pocketed coil design so it can also minimize motion transfer while providing support. The comfort layer consists of soft foams and high density foams to provide comfort.

Signature Sleep – Signature

Signature Sleep Signature 13 Inch MattressThe Signature 13″ Mattress from Signature Sleep is a very budget friendly innerspring mattress that has a memory foam layer. It’s a good option for a guest room or you can use it as your regular mattress. The only issue that we have with this mattress is the particularly short warranty period of 1 year.

  • Support Layer: 744 Individually Wrapped Coils
  • Comfort Layer: Pillow top with Memory Foam, 3 zone foam layers
  • Fabric: Bamboo Rayon Quilted Cover
  • Firmness: Soft – Medium Firm
  • Available Sizes: Full, Queen
  • Thickness: 13″
  • Product Page: Click Here

Having 744 individually wrapped coils and a memory foam layer is very good for this price. However, as we mentioned above, the 1 year warranty can be an issue. Also, it only comes in two sizes, Full and Queen, so if you need a different mattress size, you need to look at other mattresses.

Night Therapy Deluxe Spring Mattress

Night Therapy DeluxeNight Therapy is part of the Zinus brand and they offer budget innerspring and memory foam mattresses. The 13″ Deluxe Euro Box Top Spring Mattress is the thickest innerspring mattress from them. It’s a very good deal considering that it has pocketed coils and 10 years warranty.

  • Support Layer: 690 Pocketed Coils
  • Comfort Layer: 3″ High density foam, Quilted 2″ euro top with 1.5″ soft foam
  • Fabric: Polyester jacquard quilted
  • Firmness: Firm
  • Available Sizes: Full, Queen, King
  • Thickness: 13″
  • Product Page: Click Here

Night Therapy is a good brand if you are in need of a budget mattress for guest rooms or temporary use. Customers that bought a mattress from them are satisfied but of course, there are a few that weren’t. If you like a firm mattress, this is a good option.

Englander Finale

englander-finale-fullThe Englander Finale is a 10″ mattress with a 3-zone support feature. The 3-zone support system is a feature wherein different gauges of coil are used in different areas for a more effective support. The shoulder area has a 14.5 gauge spring, the lumbar area has a 14 gauge spring and the leg area uses a 14.5 gauge spring. The springs in the lumbar area are firmer to reduce back problems.

  • Support Layer: Individually wrapped coils
  • Comfort Layer: Polyfoam + plush top layer
  • Fabric: Polyester-blend
  • Firmness: soft – medium soft
  • Available Sizes: Twin, Twin, XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal-King
  • Thickness: 10″
  • Product Page: Click Here

The Englander Finale is made in the USA and the foam is CertiPUR-US certified. This is a mattress that can provide good comfort and support at a very affordable price. The only thing we could see as an issue is the very short 1 year warranty. Other than that, it is a good mattress considering its price. We recommend it as a guest room or temporary mattress.


Innerspring Mattress Guide

Here are some things that you need to know about innerspring mattresses. We’ve stated before that there are 4 common coil designs that are used in the construction of an innerspring mattress. Here they are and how they differ from one another.

Coil Designs

Bonnell Coils or open coils are very commonly used in many low priced mattresses. They are shaped like an hour glass and are connected with each other. This particular type of design can provide great support as long as the wires are heavy (gauge 12-13). Motion isolation can be an issue with this type of coil design.

Offset Coils are quite similar to Bonnell coils in design but with some changes. The changes made it possible for this design to contour to your body better and provide better motion isolation. This design is usually found in more expensive mattresses.

Continuous Coils can be very durable due to the nature of how it is designed. It consists of many coils that are made from one continuous steel wire. As a result, they can get support from adjacent coils to improve durability. This design can be very firm but the main issues are contouring and motion isolation.

Pocketed coils are the “high-end” in the coil design hierarchy. It is the most popular coil design today because of its superior performance. This design system consists of individual coils that are wrapped in fabric. They are joined together using fabric, glue or other materials. Since the coils are independent of each other, the results are better body contouring and motion isolation while still providing great support.

Coil Gauge and Coil Count

Coil gauge usually ranges from 12 to 18 and the lower the number, the thicker the wire. A thicker wire will result in a more supportive and firmer base. Coil count is the number of coils used in the support layer. The higher the coil count, the more expensive the mattress will be. The importance of the coil count is relative to the design and gauge of the wires used in the construction of the mattress. If the wires are heavy (12-13 gauge), a lower coil count is acceptable but if the wires are lighter, a higher coil count is required to be able to provide optimum support.

Additional Tips

The thickness of your mattress is purely depending on your preference if you are of average height and weight. A thinner mattress is usually more firm so keep that in mind. If you are, however, a fairly large person (more than 250lbs), a thicker mattress, 10″+, will be more suitable because it will provide ample support and comfort.

With regards to the foundation, you have the option of buying one or not. However, innerspring mattresses can perform better and last longer if it has a good foundation. The foundation can act as a “shock absorber” and as a result, the stress on the mattress is reduced. If you are going to buy one, it’s best to get the one that is recommended by the seller so as not to have problems with warranty, if you ever need to use it.

Summary

Innerspring mattresses are still very popular to this day and one of the reasons is that they are very affordable. The prices are relatively low if you compare it to memory foam mattresses and latex mattresses with the same thickness. However, just because they are cheaper, that doesn’t mean that they are inferior. One thing that works in favor of innerspring mattresses is that there are many options to choose from regardless of how much your budget is. Hopefully, you found our innerspring mattress reviews to be helpful.